Volume 12, Issue 1

 January 2014
Sorensen, Eli Park . 2014. Korean Adoption Literature and the Politics of Representation. Partial Answers 12(1): 155-179. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/535671. Publisher's Version

This article discusses the challenges involved in the formation of a “genre” of Korean adoptee autobiographical writing. It provides a brief outline of the political and historical background of the phenomenon of Korean international adoption and discuss a text that frames some of the problems involved in defining the genre of Korean adoptee autobiography — namely Marie Myung-Ok Lee’s Somebody’s Daughter (2005). The author of this book was not adopted, and the book is a novel, a fictional text; at the same time, given the fact that half of the text is written in first-person — a Korean adoptee recounting her return to Korea — Somebody’s Daughter at times resembles an adoptee autobiography in an uncanny way. This resemblance is further enhanced by the fact that neither the text nor the paratext indicate whether the author is an adoptee or not. The book is indirectly offering the illusion of an “authentic” testimony of adoptee experience (it has indeed been used in academic contexts as an example thereof). But does it matter that the author was not adopted? Would it have made any difference — and for whom — had she been an adoptee? Is it even possible to speak of an “authentic” testimony of adoptee experience, regardless of whether the author is an adoptee or not? The article attempts to clarify some of these issues, while arguing that a novel like Lee’s challenges the genre of adoptee autobiography but also helps to define its potential.

 

Eli Park Sorensen is an assistant professor at the College of Liberal Studies at Seoul National University, specializing in postcolonial studies, comparative literature, and cultural studies. He received his Ph.D. in Comparative Literature from University College London in 2007. Prior to Seoul National University, he worked at Kyung Hee University and Cambridge University. He has published Postcolonial Studies and the Literary with Palgrave Macmillan (2010), as well as articles in collections and journals, including Paragraph, Journal of Narrative Theory, NOVEL: A Forum on Fiction, Explicator, Research in African Literatures, Modern Drama, and Forum for Modern Language Studies.

 

Feldman, Daniel . 2014. Poetry in Question: The Interrogative Lyric of Yeats's Major Poems. Partial Answers 12(1): 87-105. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/535668. Publisher's Version

Questions play a prominent role in W. B. Yeats’s mature work. This essay discusses the use of questions in three of Yeats’s most renowned interrogative lyrics: “The Second Coming,” “Leda and the Swan,” and “Among School Children.” By reviewing the critical discourse regarding these canonical texts and locating a key semantic commonality linking the three poems, the article posits that questions reveal a revolutionary approach to epistemology that distinguishes Yeats as a poet whose lyric form breaks the monologic mold. Yeats’s interrogative verse is ultimately shown to offer a new form of dialogic knowledge that addresses an interrogated other as a means of inquiring what wisdom poetry affords in a world beset by epistemic doubt.

January 2014: Daniel Feldman teaches in the Department of English at Bar-Ilan University. 

His article on subjectivity in the poetry of Paul Celan and Dan Pagis is forthcoming in appears in the Winter 2014 issue of Comparative Literature.

 

Speicher, Allison . 2014. A Space for Science: Science Education and the Domestic in Louisa May Alcott's Little Men. Partial Answers 12(1): 63-85. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/535667. Publisher's Version

In mid-nineteenth century America, science education was often presented as a panacea, capable of providing students with mental discipline, moral instruction, and useful knowledge.  In her 1871 novel, Little Men, Louisa May Alcott assesses the ability of science education to fulfill these aims, selectively embracing some of the beliefs, goals, and methods promoted by advocates of science education while critiquing others.  Unlike these advocates, Alcott highlights the differences between children and their diverse educational goals, presenting science education chiefly as a means to an end. Alcott’s investment in science education is tempered by her commitment to moral and domestic education. Through the character of Dan she demonstrates that increased scientific literacy does not necessarily lead to moral growth or future domestic happiness.  Instead, science and the domestic prove incommensurable throughout the novel: the students who most heartily embrace science, Dan and Nan, are also the most decidedly undomestic graduates of Plumfield, as their science education gives them access to alternatives to home life, for good or for ill.

 

January 2014: Allison Speicher is a Ph.D. candidate in the English Department at Indiana University Bloomington.  She is currently completing a dissertation entitled “Schooling Readers: Reading Common Schools in Nineteenth-Century American Literature,” which focuses on the relationship between fiction and school reform.

 

Astro, Alan . 2014. Revisiting Wiesel's Night in Yiddish, French, and English. Partial Answers 12(1): 127-153. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/535670. Publisher's Version

Elie Wiesel’s Night, which first appeared in French as La nuit in 1958, may well loom as the archetypal Holocaust survivor narrative. But it was only in 1994, in his memoirs, that the author addressed the fact that Night is part adaptation, part translation, of a Yiddish work he originally published in Buenos Aires in 1956: …Un di velt hot geshvign (…And the World Was Silent). Critics have read discrepancies between the two versions in various ways: favorably, as resulting from appreciation for the distinct literary idiom of each language; provocatively, as the consequence of Wiesel’s desire to cast the Holocaust in Christian, rather than Jewish, terms; and disparagingly, as part of a strategy to hide ideologically unpalatable, ethnocentric attitudes from a wider audience.

This article reviews the merits and flaws of these interpretations of differences in versions of Night. Further, it offers a new approach that involves a re-examination of Wiesel’s relationship with François Mauriac, the towering writer who encouraged his entry into French letters.

 

January 2014: Alan Astro is professor of modern languages at Trinity University in San Antonio, Texas. He is the author of over thirty articles on writers as varied as Bashevis, Baudelaire, Beckett and Borges. Astro is the editor of Yiddish South of the Border: An Anthology of Latin American Yiddish Writing (University of New Mexico Press). His entry on Yiddish has just appeared in a social history of languages in France, published by the University of Rennes.

 

Salminen, Antti . 2014. On Breathroutes: Paul Celan's Poetics of Breathing. Partial Answers 12(1): 107-126. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/535669. Publisher's Version

The article explores the thematics of breathing in Paul Celan’s (1920–1970) poems and poetics. It is argued that in Celan breathing is a holistic phenomenon and an essential part of the poems’ materiality, a force that animates both the poetic and bodily corpus. Thus we ask here, by what poetic means written and oral word and respiration are connected. The bodily, temporal, spiritual, inspirational and interpretational aspects of breathing are addressed in order to understand how respiration as a bodily phenomenon becomes poetic and what kind of thematics are thus evoked. Exploring these thematics, including divine inspiration, asubjective experience, and non-causal temporality, Celan’s oeuvre is read in the context of Büchner, Heidegger, Mandelstam, and Abulafia.

 

Antti Salminen is adjunct professor at University of Tampere, spezialized in philosophy of literature and historical avant-garde. He is editor-in-chief of the quarterly philosophical review niin & näin.

 

updated September 30, 2013

Irmscher, Christoph . 2014. Susan Fenimore Cooper's Ecology of Reading. Partial Answers 12(1): 41-61. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/535666. Publisher's Version

 

Susan Fenimore Cooper’s slow-moving nature journal, Rural Hours (1850), is an education of the senses in which both author and reader learn where to look and how to look.  Her creative decision represent herself as a “gleaner” and to both use and subtly subvert the seasonal cycle (so that we may see more deeply, more intimately, more truthfully) is part of a larger critique of the paternalistic spirit that helped found the very place she writes about — Cooperstown, New York. More unobtrusively than Thoreau, Cooper develops her own sophisticated version of an “ecology of reading,” brilliantly anticipating recent attempts by ecocritics to imagine a “democracy of all life-forms” (Timothy Morton).

 

Christoph Irmscher is Provost Professor of English at Indiana University Bloomington. His books include The Poetics of Natural HistoryLongfellow Redux, and Public Poet, Private Man as well as the co-edited collection A Keener Perception:  Ecocritical Studies in American Art History (with Alan Braddock, College of William and Mary).  For the Library of America, he has edited John James Audubon's Writings and Drawings. His most recent book, the biography Louis Agassiz:  Creator of American Science, published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, was selected as “Editor’s Choice” by the New York Times Book Review.  Christoph Irmscher’s fields of expertise include 19th and 20th century American and Canadian literature, with a special focus on nature and science writing, history of the book, and poetry.  He was featured in two documentaries about John James Audubon, the award-winning American Masters program Drawn from Nature and, more recently, A Summer of Birds, produced by Louisiana Public Television.  His online exhibit on H. W Longfellow won a Leab Award from the Rare Books and Manuscripts Section of the Association of College and Research Libraries. He can be reached through his homepage at www.christophirmscher.com.

updated in June 2014

 
Franke, William . 2014. Canonicity, Creativity, and the Unlimited Revelation of Literature. Partial Answers 12(1): 1-24. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/535664. Publisher's Version

Developing in a specifically religious register a poetic epistemology, this essay argues for rehabilitating revelation as a model of knowing that challenges some of our modern and especially postmodern prejudices against striving to envision truth as a whole. It aligns these results with some of the recent advances in critical theory, for example, by Frederic Jameson, Eric Santner, and Slavoj Zizek, who likewise attempt to break through the confinements of strictly scientific epistemology. Extending the range of such contemporary critiques in directions suggested by Rosenzweig, Benjamin, and Blanchot, the essay exposes the deep roots in canonical and classical humanities tradition of such revisionary thinking of knowledge as finally a form of “revelation.” The kind of wholeness and the ideal of universality embodied in the epic and in humanities knowledge in general appear in a striking new light based not on the concept, with its inevitably exclusionary logic (A versus not-A) but rather on a negative-theological thinking of the not-All which involves, nevertheless, a relatedness to all without restrictions or exclusions.  This thinking-beyond-the-concept is shown to drive the dynamics of imaginative expression striving towards epic wholeness.

 

January 2014: William Franke is Professor of Philosophy and Religions at the University of Macao and Professor of Comparative Literature at Vanderbilt University. He is research fellow of the Alexander von Humboldt-Stiftung and has been Fulbright Distinguished Chair in Intercultural Theology at the University of Salzburg. As a philosopher of the humanities with a negative theological vision of the origin and significance of human culture, he elaborates a theological poetics in books including Dante’s Interpretive Journey (Chicago, 1996), Poetry and Apocalypse (Stanford, 2009), and Dante and the Sense of Transgression (London, 2012). His apophatic philosophy is directly developed in On What Cannot Be Said (Notre Dame, 2007) and A Philosophy of the Unsayable (Notre Dame, forthcoming).

 

Barnard, Teresa . 2014. Thomas Day: Portrait of a Gentleman. Partial Answers 12(1): 25-40. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/535665. Publisher's Version

The narrative of Joseph Wright’s figures is eloquent and complex. In many ways, the sitters defined themselves and their cultural aspirations for posterity through clothing, posture and props. However, Wright subverts the tenets of eighteenth-century portraiture as he attempts to identify the physical markers that give the viewer a closer understanding of character. The painting of Thomas Day, for example, is far removed from the conventional portraiture of the wealthy gentleman. Its signifiers suggest the complexities of Day’s character. Most of what we know of the eccentric Day has come to us through Anna Seward’s unorthodox biography of Erasmus Darwin and his circle. This text is supplemented by letters between Seward and Walter Scott, which disclose the publishing censorship levelled at her memoir of Day when she attempted to find a psychological cause for his experiments with education and his rejection of wealth and luxury. Her private letters give an alternative view of the public figure that was part of her literary coterie, her “dear Quartetto.” This essay discusses the representation of character in Wright’s portrait of Thomas Day and decodes its cultural markers through a synthesis of painting and word-painting.

 

Teresa Barnard is senior lecturer at the University of Derby, United Kingdom, teaching eighteenth- and nineteenth-century literature, and Derbyshire literature from the eighteenth century to the present day. Her research interests are in the area of long eighteenth-century women’s writing, and she has published several articles and chapters on the subject, including “Anna Seward’s Terrestrial Year: Women, Poetry and Science in Eighteenth-Century England” for Partial Answers and “‘The Midnight and Poetic Pageant’: An evening of Romance and Chivalry” for Cultural History. Her monograph, Anna Seward: A Constructed Life, a critical biography based on Seward’s unpublished manuscripts and censored letters, was published with Ashgate in 2009. She is currently working on a book of essays, British Women and the Intellectual World in the Long Eighteenth Century, also with Ashgate. She is advisor for the eighteenth century for the Turku Centre for Medieval and Early Modern Studies.

Updated September 10, 2013