Zirker, Angelika . 2011.
“Physiognomy and the Reading of Character in Our Mutual Friend”.
Partial Answers 9(2): 379-390. .
Publisher's VersionIn Our Mutual Friend, Charles Dickens uses physiognomy as an indirect way of portraying characters that observe their fellow-characters rather than as a direct means of portraying the characters observed. This reading of faces often constitutes misinterpretation: Dickens links Our Mutual Friend to the issue of reading itself, providing models of reader response. Misreadings thus become morally and aesthetically relevant to the overall structure and effect of the novel.
June 2011: Dr. Angelika Zirker is a research assistant and lecturer of English philology at Eberhard Karls University in Tübingen, Germany. Her PhD (published in 2010) is about The Pilgrim as a Child: Concepts of Play, Language and Salvation in Lewis Carroll’s Alice Books. She is an associate member of the postgraduate programme Dimensions of Ambiguity, and co-editor of Connotations: A Journal for Critical Debate. Her research interests and publications include Shakespeare, Early Modern Poetry, children’s literature and concepts of childhood, literature and ethics, as well as nineteenth-century literature and culture, with a strong emphasis on the novel. Her current project deals with the relations between poetry and the stage during the Early Modern period, with a particular focus on Sir Philip Sidney, William Shakespeare, and John Donne. |
|
|
Harris, Carole K. . 2011.
“The Politics of the Cliché: Flannery O'Connor's 'Revelation' and 'The Displaced Person'”.
Partial Answers 9(1): 111-129. .
Publisher's VersionFlannery O'Connor did not see herself as a political writer, and many critics perpetuate her self-image in their assessment of her work. She was, however, a keen observer of the politics of everyday conversation. By exploring the ritualized exchange of clichés between employer and hired help, particularly in "Revelation" (1964) and "The Displaced Person" (1954), this essay examines the ways in which O'Connor draws attention to the peculiar collective power of the cliché. The two stories demonstrate the politics of the cliché in her fiction, a phenomenon some critics overlook because they assume, as many of O'Connor's characters do, that clichés are empty platitudes. "Revelation" dramatizes the politics of the cliché in a democratic setting, whereas "The Displaced Person" calls attention to the way in which clichés confirm and contest hierarchies of power in the master-servant relationship. In "Revelation," the seemingly benign (and often hilarious) exchange of clichés between two key female characters serves to exclude a third party. The ritualization of their exchange, however, and the assumption that clichés are banal, mask this act of exclusion. "The Displaced Person" also stars two female characters who exchange clichés to exclude an outsider, and because clichés have the ability to echo unexpectedly across conversations, they function both inside and outside the women's relationship. A variety of other speakers draw on a communal stock and recycle the same clichés. The regularities with which clichés and silences circulate in the conversations between the two key characters can thus be extrapolated to a network of other relationships within the story. Over time, a single act of exclusion on the part of two characters develops the potential to trigger escalating acts of aggression, verbal and physical. "The Displaced Person" suggests that clichés carry unexpected and potentially ever graver consequences in a collective context. "Revelation" and "The Displaced Person" enable O'Connor to explore issues of democracy in a new way; read in the context of each other, they highlight the political and ethical significance of clichés, in particular their relation to violence.
January 2011: Carole K. Harris is a professor of literature and writing at New York City College of Technology, City University of New York. She received her B. A. in French Literature from Duke University and her Ph. D. in Comparative Literature from Yale University. Her early scholarship focused on the received idea in Flaubert. Currently, she is at work on a collection of essays entitled Flannery O’Connor: The Politics of the Cliché, as well as a creative non-fiction piece on three generations of her family. Through her photography, exhibited in local venues, she also explores the cliché as a visual phenomenon. |
|
|
Kearful, Frank J. . 2011.
“A. R. Ammons's Levity”.
Partial Answers 9(1): 153-175. .
Publisher's VersionYou can locate A. R. Ammons in a line of great walkers from Wordsworth to Frank O'Hara, but what makes him different from all the rest is that despite being so peripatetic, he could not keep his feet on the ground. In poem after poem he, or a stand-in protagonist, not only turns, spins, and whirls, but rises, ascends, levitates. Thereafter comes in due course a descent, sometimes an arduous or scarifying one, but which typically finds him the better off after his return to terra firma. Levity in the transferred sense - Ammons was a whimsical, voluble, unbuttoned humorist - proves useful in contending with the perilous consequences of his levitations. In addition to his drollery, Ammons sporadically employs a prophetic voice, meditates on philosophical issues, and delves expertly into phenomena privy to the natural scientist. The composite result is a style of levity entirely his own. The extent to which he may, as a consequence of his levity, or in spite of it, be enrolled in a transcendentalist tradition of the visionary sublime stretching back to Emerson, as Harold Bloom would have it, is debatable. Five poems examined very closely give a slant on the issues involved, "Moment," "Transcendence," "He Held Radical Light," "Levitation," and "Hymn." Other Ammons poems are discussed briefly, and incidental comparisons are made to poems by Walt Whitman, Wallace Stevens, Theodore Roethke, Elizabeth Bishop, Robert Lowell, Sylvia Plath, and John Ashbery.
Frank Kearful is Professor of English at Bonn University, where he has taught since 1974. He has been a visiting professor at Tübingen University and Hamburg University, and before moving to Germany in 1972 he was an Associate Professor of English and Comparative Literature at the University of Washington. He has written numerous articles on twentieth-century American poetry, is editor of The Robert Lowell Newsletter, and since 2003 he has written the annual chapter on American poetry since the 1940s for American Literary Scholarship. Updated July 29, 2011 |
|
|
frank_kearful.jpg Baumgarten, Murray . 2011.
“Reading Dickens Writing London”.
Partial Answers 9(2): 219-231. .
Publisher's VersionCarlyle's view of modern life as a palimpsest serves as a postulate for his Victorian contemporaries and successors, who make it into the defining idea of the modern city. Following Carlyle's lead, they explore the urban palimpsest, yet nor for them is his prophetic voice of guilt and punishment. Rather, in exploring the uneasy pleasures in the juxtaposition of the urban layers of modern experience, in The Pickwick Papers, Bleak House, Little Dorrit, Our Mutual Friend and other novels Dickens strikes the modern note of the attraction of repulsion as well as shifting, alternating, alternative realities. The boundaries of class and species are honeycombed by pathways which hum with traffic and constant crossings of the layers of the palimpsest of modern urban life, and the reader navigates among unstable places together with the narrators who are often split and divided along the fault lines of urban life.
Murray Baumgarten is Research Professor of Literature and Distinguished Emeritus Professor of English and Comparative Literature at the University of California, Santa Cruz, Founding Director of the Dickens Project of the University of California, and Emeritus Editor of Judaism. He is the author of Carlyle and His Era (1975), Carlyle: Books & Margins (1980), City Scriptures: Modern Jewish Writing (1982), and numerous articles on nineteenth-century English literature as well as on American-Jewish writers. With Barbara Gottfried he has co-authored Understanding Philip Roth (1990). He has served as Editor in Chief of the California Strouse Carlyle Edition and has co-edited Homes and Homelessness in the Victorian Imagination (1999, with H. M. Daleski) and Jewish Culture and the Hispanic World: Essays in Memory of Joseph H. Silverman (2001, with Samuel G. Armistead, Mishael M. Caspi, and Juan de la Cuesta). He is a Founding Board Member of the Venice Center for International Jewish Studies. Updated: March 20, 2016 |
|
|
murray_baumgarten.jpg Puckett, Kent . 2011.
“Some Versions of Syllepsis”.
Partial Answers 9(1): 177-188. .
Publisher's VersionThe essay takes up Garrett Stewart's recent discussion (Partial Answers 8.1) of the ethical tempo of a rhetorical figure, syllepsis, in order to think through some temporal consequences of the ethical turn.
January 2011: Kent Puckett is Associate Professor of English at the University of California at Berkeley. He is author of Bad Form: Social Mistakes and the Nineteenth-Century Novel (Oxford University Press, 2008). |
|
|
Malone, Irina Ruppo . 2011.
“Spectral History: The Ghost Stories of Dorothy Macardle”.
Partial Answers 9(1): 95-109. .
Publisher's VersionThe article focuses on Earth-Bound: Nine Stories of Ireland (1924), a collection of ghost stories composed by Dorothy Macardle, a prolific Irish author, historian, and political journalist. The article demonstrates how Tzvetan Todorov's concept of the reader's hesitation, as central to the fantastic (and by extension the gothic genre), helps one understand Macardle's engagement with the sacrificial ideology of Irish nationalism. Macardle's collection of stories of supernatural apparitions during the troubled 1920s makes Irish history the sphere of the fantastic. It makes the reader hesitate - not between the different approaches to the supernatural - but between the conflicting ideological positions presented in the text.
January 2011: Irina Ruppo Malone is a graduate of Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Trinity College Dublin, and National University of Ireland, Galway, where she held a Postdoctoral Fellowship funded by the Irish Council for the Humanities and Social Sciences and has taught courses on Irish literature and theatre. She is the author of Ibsen and the Irish Revival (Palgrave, 2010). |
|
|
Paroissien, David . 2011.
“Subdued by the Dyer's Hand: Dickens at Work in Bleak House”.
Partial Answers 9(2): 285-295. .
Publisher's VersionThis essay examines the implications of Dickens's statement in the preface to the one-volume edition of Bleak House (September 1853) that in the novel he "purposely dwelt upon the romantic side of familiar things." This claim, I argue, goes to the core of Dickens's art as a writer, an art that combines the presentation of disturbing news about the contemporary state of society with a skilful attempt to provide narrative pleasure, pleasure designed to ensure that the narrator retains his hold over readers for 67 chapters. Dickens's achievement, I conclude, constitutes literary art of the highest order, one that instructs readers in social and ethical truths while also delighting them and holding their attention in the course of telling a compelling story.
June 2011: David Paroissien, Emeritus Professor of English, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, and Professorial Research Fellow, University of Buckingham, edits Dickens Quarterly and co-edits The Dickens Companion Series with Susan Shatto. He has contributed two volumes to the series (Oliver Twist and Great Expectations) and has recently edited A Companion to Charles Dickens (2008), a series of essays contributed by Dickensian scholars from around the world, designed to place Dickens’s writing in its literary and historical context. He is currently working on a project related to Dickens’s political views and his writing about history. |
|
|
Wallen, Jeffrey . 2011.
“Twemlow's Abyss”.
Partial Answers 9(2): 391-403. .
Publisher's VersionThe paper demonstrates that Dickens's Our Mutual Friend complicates any attempt to differentiate between aesthetic enjoyment and social awareness in reader response. It isolates three models of reading in which the interconnection between aesthetic effect and consciousness-raising effect is associated with the entanglements between person and thing, animate and inanimate, living and dead, subject and object of perception. These entanglements destabilize the grounds on which we would usually differentiate between aesthetic pleasure and social critique.
Jeffrey Wallen is Professor of Comparative Literature at Hampshire College, in Amherst, Massachusetts. He is author of Closed Encounters: Literary Politics and Public Culture (University of Minnesota Press, 1998). In addition to writing about the current conflicts and debates in the university, he has published widely on nineteenth-century European literature. His essays have appeared in Yale Journal of Criticism, ELH, Diacritics, Word & Image, College English, a/b: Auto/Biography Studies, and other journals. His most recent publications include "Migrant Visions: The Scheunenviertel and Boyle Heights, Los Angeles," "Narrative Tensions: The Eyewitness and the Archive," "Falling Under an Evil Influence," "From the Archives" (co-written with Arnold Dreyblatt), and "Sociable Robots and the Posthuman." He is currently working on a study of the archive in contemporary thought and art. Updated February 19, 2011 |
|
|
jeffrey_wallen.jpg Ciugureanu, Adina . 2011.
“The Victim-Aggressor Duality in Great Expectations”.
Partial Answers 9(2): 347-361. .
Publisher's VersionThe article focuses on the aggressor-victim paradigms upon which Dickens builds three of his female characters in Great Expectations: Mrs. Joe Gargery, Miss Havisham, and Molly. Usually described as monstrous, the three characters are here discussed in terms of the hidden motives of their strange behavior, one of the sources of uneasy pleasures in the reading process. Viewed from the feminist standpoint, the representation of the three characters is associated with Victorian views concerning the treatment of women, sexuality, crime, and marriage; viewed in psychological terms, all the three display symptoms of narcissistic personality disorder, wit the roles of victim and aggressor shifting over time.
June 2011: Adina Ciugureanu is Professor of English and American literature and culture at Ovidius University Constanta. She is currently the Dean of the Faculty of Letters, Director of the Research Center for Cross-Cultural Studies and editor of the Annals of Ovidius University (the Philology Series). She is President of the Romanian Association for American Studies (RAAS), affiliated to the European Association for American Studies (EAAS), and member of the Romanian-German Academy. Her major publications include Modernism and the Idea of Modernity (Constanta: Ex Ponto, 2004, reprinted 2008), Victorian Selves (Constanta: Ovidius University Press, 2005, reprinted 2008), Post-War Anxieties (Constanta: Ex Ponto, 2006), The Boomerang Effect (Constanta: Ex Ponto, 2002, translated into Romanian and republished in 2008, Iashi: Institutul European) and numerous articles. |
|
|
adina_ciugureanu.jpg