Filter By Topic

Intermediality

Freedman, Ariela . 2015. Chris Ware's Epiphanic Comics. Partial Answers 13(2): 337-358. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/583341. Publisher's Version

This paper reads Chris Ware’s Building Stories in light of his many references to art and literature, especially to Cornell, Courbet, Duchamp, and James Joyce. The author argues that Building Stories requires intermedial reading, knowledge of both the “high” canon of modernist literature and art and the history and iconology of twentieth and twenty-first century comics. In Building Stories Ware incorporates the work and ideas of canonical art history through an allusive play that is hybrid, layered and subversive. The paper claims that Ware’s citation of Duchamp and Courbet reframes a dissociated and dissociating trope, the dismembered female nude, in a story critical of the objectification of women, the mask of femininity, and the traps of gender. Ware ultimately does so in the service of a sentimental and redemptive narrative frame the paper calls the epiphanic mode. As used by Ware, the epiphanic mode marries one of the most sacred and revered concepts of modernism, the epiphany, to the formal device of the comics capsule as used by Bil Keane, one of the most maligned and popular comics artists of the last fifty years. The turn towards a devalued device — the Bil Keane capsule, or epiphanic circle, and a devalued experience — the domestic, rejects the internal hierarchies not only of the art world but also of the comics world, which is so often associated with masculine and public models of heroism.

 

Ariela Freedman is an Associate Professor at the Liberal Arts College, Concordia University, Montreal. In 2009 she spent a semester as a Visiting Professor and Halbert Fellow in the English Department of Hebrew University, Jerusalem. She is the author of Death, Men and Modernism (Routledge 2003) and has published articles on modernism, the First World War, and comics in Modernism/modernity, JJQ, Literature Compass, Joyce Studies Annual, and other journals and edited collections. She currently holds a SSHRC Grant for a project titled “Charlotte Salomon, Comics and the Representation of Pain,” and her work on Salomon has appeared in Criticism and the anthology Graphic Details: Jewish Women's Confessional Comics in Essays and Interviews (McFarland 2014).

updated on March 16, 2015

 

 

Thomas, Evan . 2015. A Renaissance for Comics Studies: Early English Prints and the Comics Canon. Partial Answers 13(2): 255-266. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/583337. Publisher's Version

This paper argues that the term “comics” can and should be used to refer to prints from early modern England. We have ample reason to shift the starting date for comics to at least the seventeenth century, if not earlier, within the English-speaking world. The invention of print stimulated the creation, adoption, and codification of elements of the comics form. Print also changed the quantity and quality of social encounters with the comics form. Readings from “A true discourse. Declaring the damnable life and death of one Stubbe Peeter” and The Triumphs of God’s Revenge Against the Crying and Execrable Sinne of Murther demonstrate that scholars of the comics canon must turn their attention to the early modern English print.

 

 

June 2015: Evan Thomas is a PhD candidate in Early Modern English literature at the Ohio State University. His publications have appeared in Multicultural Comics and the journal Reformation. His forthcoming dissertation addresses printed image-texts from early modern England, including works related to Spenser, Shakespeare, Middleton, and Milton.

 

Clapp, Jeffrey . 2015. Nicotine Cosmopolitanism: From Italo Svevo's Trieste to Art Spiegelman's New York. Partial Answers 13(2): 311-336. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/583340. Publisher's Version

Cosmopolitanism need not always be a duty, an identity, or a condition; it can just as easily be a moment or a memory, an experience that can vanish in a puff of smoke. This article explores the surprisingly similar ways that Zeno’s Conscience (1923) by Italo Svevo and In the Shadow of No Towers (2004) by Art Spiegelman imaginatively reframe cosmopolitanism through the figure of cigarette smoking. In particular, it expands attention to No Towers past the discourse of trauma and connects the new graphic canon to a canonical work of literary modernism. The chain-smoking figures at the center of these two texts give us an image of the cosmopolitan which is reducible neither to the Enlightenment ideal of the supranational liberal citizen, nor to its contemporary idiom, the fluid and flexible post-identitarian subject. Instead, both writers use cigarette smoking to delineate an apt cosmopolitan resident for two cities on the verge of being transformed by warlike nationalisms. Where Svevo uses nicotine addiction to connect his twitchy protagonist to prewar Trieste, Spiegelman insistently, but ironically accumulates forms of memory and identity around smoking, from his image as human and as “Maus,” to the smoke of the ovens at Auschwitz, to the burning of the Towers themselves. But this work of belonging is interrupted in No Towers by the New York City smoking ban, which displaces an apoplectic Spiegelman from his briefly “rooted” cosmopolitanism. Ultimately, this article explores an unlikely seam of detail, and a consistent image of the cosmopolitan, which persists across the borders between the twentieth century and the twenty-first, between the modern and the postmodern, and between the First World War and the War on Terror.

 

June 2015: Jeffrey Clapp works in the Department of Literature and Cultural Studies at the Hong Kong Institute of Education. He is the coeditor of Security and Hospitality in Literature and Culture: Modern and Contemporary Perspectives (Routledge 2016), and he is working on a book about surveillance, democracy, and literature from the Cold War to the present.

 

Barnard, Teresa . 2014. Thomas Day: Portrait of a Gentleman. Partial Answers 12(1): 25-40. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/535665. Publisher's Version

The narrative of Joseph Wright’s figures is eloquent and complex. In many ways, the sitters defined themselves and their cultural aspirations for posterity through clothing, posture and props. However, Wright subverts the tenets of eighteenth-century portraiture as he attempts to identify the physical markers that give the viewer a closer understanding of character. The painting of Thomas Day, for example, is far removed from the conventional portraiture of the wealthy gentleman. Its signifiers suggest the complexities of Day’s character. Most of what we know of the eccentric Day has come to us through Anna Seward’s unorthodox biography of Erasmus Darwin and his circle. This text is supplemented by letters between Seward and Walter Scott, which disclose the publishing censorship levelled at her memoir of Day when she attempted to find a psychological cause for his experiments with education and his rejection of wealth and luxury. Her private letters give an alternative view of the public figure that was part of her literary coterie, her “dear Quartetto.” This essay discusses the representation of character in Wright’s portrait of Thomas Day and decodes its cultural markers through a synthesis of painting and word-painting.

 

Teresa Barnard is senior lecturer at the University of Derby, United Kingdom, teaching eighteenth- and nineteenth-century literature, and Derbyshire literature from the eighteenth century to the present day. Her research interests are in the area of long eighteenth-century women’s writing, and she has published several articles and chapters on the subject, including “Anna Seward’s Terrestrial Year: Women, Poetry and Science in Eighteenth-Century England” for Partial Answers and “‘The Midnight and Poetic Pageant’: An evening of Romance and Chivalry” for Cultural History. Her monograph, Anna Seward: A Constructed Life, a critical biography based on Seward’s unpublished manuscripts and censored letters, was published with Ashgate in 2009. She is currently working on a book of essays, British Women and the Intellectual World in the Long Eighteenth Century, also with Ashgate. She is advisor for the eighteenth century for the Turku Centre for Medieval and Early Modern Studies.

Updated September 10, 2013