Volume 15, issue 1

January 2017
Davidi, Einat . 2018. The Jewish Petenera: Profile of a Spanish Myth. Partial Answers 16(1): 27-41. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/684667. Publisher's Version

The paper deals with the nature of the genre of Flamenco known as Petenera, which in the past was erroneously attributed a Jewish origin. The comparative analysis of multiple variations of texts produced for this genre suggests that it subsumes within it the memory of a historical trauma related to the vanishing and absence of Jews since the end of the 15th century and that this memory is expressed both in performative aspects of the genre and in folkloric perceptions of it. The image of the Jew is present in collective consciousness and manifests itself as part of the system of textual conventions of an art form that has a folkloric component and folkloric origin. Within the conventions of this genre, expressions of the attitude toward the Jewish “ghost” are welded to a gendered layer — the bearer of this image is a woman, and the analysis shows that the texts embody different variations of the same recurring themes and features: eros, sin, guilt, remorse, and a touch of morbidity. The argument here is that palo (Spanish for “a genre of Flamenco”) contains a literary-textual component, an element of content, and not just musical components. These folkloric texts should be given a closer reading; the analysis perfomed in this paper is one way of doing so. 

 

Einat Davidi, author of Paradiso as Pardes: A Contrapuntal Reading of José Lezama Limas’ Poetology and the Cabalistic Theory of Language and History (Wilhelm Fink Verlag, 2012) and of several articles on Cuban Literature (José Lezama Lima, Guillermo Rosales) and Spanish Baroque literature (Calderón de la Barca, Antonio Enríquez Gómez) is faculty member at the department of Hebrew and Comparative Literature at the University of Haifa. 

  updated in April 2020

Kinzel, Till . 2017. Narrativity and Sound in German Radio Play Adaptations of Paul Auster's The New York Trilogy. Partial Answers 15(1): 151-165. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/646679. Publisher's Version

 

 

In line with the strong emphasis on visuality in the wake of the “visual turn” in literary and cultural studies, graphic novel adaptations of literary texts have recently been the objects of scholarly study and narratological theory building. Much less attention, if any, has been accorded to radio play adaptations of novels like Paul Auster’s New York Trilogy. An analysis of radio play adaptations acquires a special significance in the case of this highly enigmatic work, which makes a seriously playful use of postmodern narrative strategies. It is perhaps above all this feature which made the adaptation of the novel’s first instalment, City of Glass, into a graphic novel by Paul Karasik and David Mazucchelli so successful. While the graphic novel visualizes characteristic features of its mother text, this paper explores the different modes of narrative sound in three German radio play adaptations of Auster’s novel. Alfred Behrens’ Stadt aus Glas, Katharina Bihler’s Schlagschatten, and Norbert Schaeffer’s Hinter verschlossenen Türen employ narrative devices like voices in both German and English, the evocation of city soundscapes, the narrative uses of music as well as issues of the simultaneity and/or difference of story and discourse time. The narrative auralization of Auster’s novels in the radio plays under discussion can be shown to foreground non-visual aspects of the pre-texts and to add further dimensions for interpretation that underline the usefulness of audionarratological analysis for adaptation studies. 

 

January 2017: Till Kinzel received his Dr. Phil. (2002) and Habilitation (2005) from the Tech­nical University of Berlin. He has published books on Allan Bloom (Platonische Kulturkritik in Amerika; 2002), Nicolás Gómez Dávila (2003, 4th enlarged ed. forthcoming), Philip Roth (Die Tragödie und Komödie des amerikanischen Lebens, 2006) and Michael Oakeshott (2007). Most recently, he has edited writings by J. J. Eschenburg (Kleine Geschichte des Romans von der Antike bis zur Aufklärung, 2014) and Edward Gibbon and co-edited Imaginary Dialogues in English (2012) and Imaginary Dialogues in American Literature and Philosophy (2014) and Audionarratology: Interfaces of Sound and Narrative (2016; with Jarmila Mildorf), as well as books on the reception of Edward Gibbon in Germany (2015) and on the poet and translator Johann Arnold Ebert (2016). Current research interests include dialogue poetry as well as the literature and philosophy of the German and British Enlightenments.

 

 

Melcer-Padon, Nourit . 2017. Romain Gary and the Aesthetics of Survival: From Genghis Cohn to King Solomon. Partial Answers 15(1): 47-60. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/646672. Publisher's Version

In many of his novels, Romain Gary depicts modes of survival during WWII. Yet survival is not restricted to times of war: in times of peace too, one must use whatever means at one’s disposal in order to survive life’s many challenges. Humor, cynicism, madness, revenge, benevolence, murder, as well as marriage, child bearing, and writing are presented as plausible mechanisms of survival. The common denominator for these methods can be termed “bricolage”: an imperfect yet possible reliance on random components, as well as on hope and imagination, to make existence liveable.Underlying the survival inventory deployed by Gary, are inescapable moral issues. None of us are exempt, and our collective consciousness forces us to realize that each of us is responsible for every kind of manifestation of human behavior. Particularly problematic is the relationship between morality and the human craving for perfection. One of the means to reach perfection is, presumably, art, made with all materials of life, the unpalatable along with the beautiful. For Gary, as long as one keeps in mind that artistic perfection is no more attainable than ridding oneself of one’s collective imperfections, the artist’s work and imagination are endowed with moral agency.

 

Nourit Melcer-Padon is senior lecturer and head of the English ESL department at the Hadassah Academic College in Jerusalem. Her research interests include comparative literature and literary theory, cultural studies, the interrelationship of history and literature, and social Jewish history.

 

Updated Sept. 8, 2019

 

 

Mildorf, Jarmila, and Till Kinzel. 2017. NARRATING SOUNDS: INTRODUCTION TO THE FORUM. Partial Answers 15(1): 61-67. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/646673. Publisher's Version

 

 

 

This introduction reflects on the links between sound, voices, music, and literature. It also delineates the main tenets of audionarratology, a branch of postclassical narratology which focuses on the interfaces between sound and narrative. The forum explores presentations of sounds, silence, and music in fiction and explores voices and soundscapes in audio drama.

   

 

Petermann, Emily . 2017. New Modes of Listening: The Mediality of Musical Novels. Partial Answers 15(1): 69-79. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/646674. Publisher's Version

A recent development in literature’s engagement with music involves the role played by emerging technologies and the way they not only transmit musical content to the listener, but very strongly condition the form the music takes and the way we listen. While music is still often considered ephemeral and transcendent, there is a new recognition of it as an object and a commodity, whether an LP record or a file to be downloaded from itunes. Technologies coexist; records are now collected and venerated in a nostalgic mode while music moves into the digital sphere of downloads and participatory cultures of online sharing. Contemporary literature can tell us not only about the idealization of music as a non-referential and thus “higher” art, but about the way music is mediated by technologies. The present paper focuses on two recent musical novels that foreground the mass media of musical expression, Nick Hornby’s High Fidelity (1995) and Arthur Phillips’s The Song Is You (2009). Both celebrate songs — incorporated as records in the former and digital files on an ipod in the latter — as symbols of taste, carriers of memory, means of establishing interpersonal connections, and media that condition our thinking. Songs also exist in relation to others, demonstrated by the protagonist’s fixation on lists modeled on radio’s top-forty rankings in High Fidelity and on juxtaposition of songs on the ipod’s shuffle mode in The Song Is You. The comparison of these novels in terms of their focus on different musical technologies leads to an exploration of modes of listening as characters experience their lives through the lens of popular music.

 

January 2017: Emily Petermann is a post-doc in American Studies and junior faculty member of the Literature Department at the University of Konstanz. She is a founding member of the Word and Music Association Forum (since 2009) and co-editor of the volume Time and Space in Words and Music (Lang 2012). Her monograph, The Musical Novel: Imitation of Musical Structure, Performance, and Reception, was published by Camden House in 2014. She is currently working on a postdoctoral book project on “Strands of Nonsense in American Literature.”

 

 

Arteel, Inge . 2017. Non-Sovereign Voices in Friederike Mayröcker's Aural Texts. Partial Answers 15(1): 135-150. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/646678. Publisher's Version

 

 

Austrian neo-avant-garde authors excelled in literary forms that foregrounded the acoustic quality of voices. Their concern was not to establish the voice as a disembodied medium of pure emotionality; rather, they experimented with the corporeal materiality and technical mediality of voice and speech, and explored the ethics and aesthetics of non-sovereign, “impure” voices. After some introductory remarks on the work of Ernst Jandl, this essay argues this stance in regard to selected texts by the Viennese author Friederike Mayröcker. In a striking awareness of the cultural history of the voice, her texts present playful parodic rewritings of traditional vocal pathos genres such as the lyrical elegy, the opera aria, and the echolalic lament. They demonstrate the appealing quality of heteronomous, dispossessed speaking or singing voices, an appeal that is well worth listening to.

 

January 2017: Inge Arteel is lecturer of German Literature at the Vrije Universiteit Brussel. Her research focuses on post-1945 Austrian literature and drama – with a particular interest in experimental writers (esp. Jelinek and Mayröcker), on text and theatricality, the radio play, and gender studies. Recent publications:

 

Arteel, Inge, and Stefan Krammer, eds. 2016. In-Differenzen: Alterität im Schreiben Josef Winklers. Tübingen: Stauffenburg.

Pewny, Katharina, and Inge Arteel. 2016. “Ritual Failure Remains? The Inaccessibility of the Dead (Corpse) in Antigone and in Contemporary Post-Conflict Art.” Forum Modernes Theater: 177–88.

Arteel, Inge. 2014. “Jelinek on the Dutch-speaking stage: From Marginal Attention to Dramaturgical Success.” Austrian Studies 22: 43–58.

Arteel, Inge. 2012. Friederike Mayröcker. Hannover: Wehrhahn.

 

 

Masing-Delic, Irene . 2017. The "Overcoat" of Nabokov's Luzhin: Defense as Self-Destruction. Partial Answers 15(1): 1-21. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/646670. Publisher's Version

This essay examines the protagonist of Nabokov’s 1930 novel The Defense as a character who has much in common with Gogol’s Bashmachkin from “The Overcoat” (1842). Both seek refuge from “real” life in their respective art: calligraphy in Bashmachkin’s case, and chess in Luzhin’s. The two protagonists’ fascination with abstract patterns and disinterest in “real” life results in a transfer of their sexuality from individuals to personified objects, or objectified people: Bashmachkin turns his overcoat into his “wife”; Luzhin gets married but turns his wife into an “overcoat” whose function it is to protect him from the chills of life. There is no “defense” against the games life that plays with the characters, however, and, like Akaky Akakievich, Luzhin destroys himself in his very quest for a protective wrap.

 

January 2017: Professor Irene Masing-Delic retired from the Ohio State University a few years ago and is now Editor of The Slavic and East European Journal, currently housed at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Her publications include Abolishing Death (1992), Exotic Moscow under Western Eyes (2009), and From Symbolism to Socialist Realism: A Reader (2011), as well as numerous articles on the “Silver Age.”

 

 

Rouyan, Anahita . 2017. Singing Thomas Pynchon's Gravity's Rainbow: Interfaces of Song, Narrative, and Sonic Performance. Partial Answers 15(1): 117-133. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/646677. Publisher's Version

Thomas Pynchon’s interest in music is audibly reflected in the rich intertextual environments of his works such as Gravity’s Rainbow, a novel which includes numerous allusions to musical pieces, descriptions of performances, and song lyrics. The latter stand out from prose narrative as they introduce new diegetic dimensions to the novel by offering playful commentary on its plot and characters. The present study examines the novel’s acoustic background, pointing to the formal structure of songs and its role in locating singing human voices in opposition to noises emitted by technological devices such as V2 rockets. A classification scheme shows how Pynchon’s formal experimentation juxtaposes written and oral variants of language, thus connecting songs to one of the novel’s thematic centers — problematics of order. This function of songs is examined in an episode of Vaslav Tchitcherine’s mission of promoting literacy among oral tribes of Kazakhstan, that serves as a commentary on the conventional character of writing systems and their ability to transform the poetic quality of language into a systematic structure.

 

 

January 2017: Anahita Rouyan is a doctoral candidate in an interdisciplinary program of Science, Cognition and Technology at the International Center for the History of Universities and Science, University of Bologna. Her dissertation project examines public discourses of experimental life sciences and evolution in the United States during the 19th and 20th century. Her work has been published in journals Utopian Studies and Orbit: Writing Around Pynchon, and she has forthcoming contribution to a collection of essays under the working title Biological Discourses: The Language of Science and Literature Around 1900 (Peter Lang).

Mildorf, Jarmila . 2017. Sounding Postmodernity: Narrative Voices in the Radio Adaptation of Alasdair Gray's Lanark. Partial Answers 15(1): 167-188. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/646680. Publisher's Version

 

 

 

Alasdair Gray’s novel Lanark: A Life in Four Books (1981) eludes generic categorization by crossing the boundaries between dystopian fiction, fantasy novel, life writing, and fiction marked by magic realism. In postmodern fashion, it plays with spatiotemporal frameworks and narrative order, shifts narrative voices, and perspectives and uses a multiplicity of presentational modes including dialogue and scholarly text commentary with encyclopedic annotations. In its “Epilogue,” the novel features metalepsis when it introduces the author, who talks to his protagonist about his work. The question arises how the novel’s radio play adaptation, first broadcast by the BBC on 1 November 2014, translates this playfulness into its own semiotic system. This paper particularly focuses on the narratological category of “voice” and explores what happens when narrators’ and characters’ voices are actualized in radio drama, how the radio play uses voice-over narration, voice qualities and the doubling of parts to create a recognizable as well as surprising aural storyworld. It also analyzes how sound techniques and music are employed to create narrative structures. Because of their medial instantaneousness and evanescence, radio plays arguably have to rely on disambiguation to make themselves accessible to a listening audience. However, as this paper shows, they also have a range of radiophonic techniques at their disposal to create narrativity on their own terms.

 

Jarmila Mildorf received her PhD in sociolinguistics from the University of Aberdeen (Scotland) and is now a Senior Lecturer of English language and literature at the University of Paderborn (Germany). She is the author of Storying Domestic Violence (2007) and has co-edited six collections of essays: Imaginary Dialogues in English: Explorations of a Literary Form (2012), The Writing Cure: Literature and Medicine in Context (2013), Magic, Science, Technology, and Literature (2nd ed. 2014), Imaginary Dialogues in American Literature and Philosophy (2014), Audionarratology: Interfaces of Sound and Narrative (2016) and Dialogue across Media (2016). She was also a guest co-editor of a special issue on Narrative: Knowing, Living, Telling (Partial Answers 6.2). Her research interests are dialogue studies, conversational storytelling, second-person narration, the medical humanities, and radio drama.

Updated in December 2018

 

 

Frischmuth, Agatha . 2017. Being Silent, Doing Nothing: Silence as a Symbol of Peace in Ivan Goncharov's Oblomov and Ha Jin's Waiting. Partial Answers 15(1): 99-115. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/646676. Publisher's Version

 

While many pre-modern narratives conventionally feature active protagonists, the transition into modernity has seen an increase in inactivity as a literary motif. The prominent European examples of this trend, such as Thomas Mann’s The Magic Mountain, Robert Musil’s The Man Without Qualities, or the plays of Samuel Beckett, however, exclude speaking from the list of negated activities, instead depicting voluble characters. This paper proposes that silent inactivity may be an Eastern (and Eastern European) notion, and offers two exemplary readings of this motif in Ivan Goncharov’s Oblomov and Ha Jin’s Waiting. Drawing from the work of Maurice Merleau-Ponty and Roland Barthes, it argues that silence, despite denoting an absence of signs, is meaningful and hermeneutically versatile. A distinction is made between communicative silence and natural silence, the first of which signifies the absence of speech in an interactive situation whereas the latter signifies verbal silence notwithstanding context and — importantly — includes natural soundscapes (as caused by weather, animals or touching objects). Through a number of close readings, natural silence is shown to function as the semantic core of the inactivity motif in that it is a central part of the strategy to attain peace, repose, and contentment. In addition, in both novels the desire for a peaceful way of life dominates the soundscape of romantic relationships. Although the protagonists fall in love with passionate women, they ultimately reject them due to the noise and upheaval they cause. The paper concludes that in connection to the motif of inactivity the notion of silent companionship outweighs that of love (associated with speech). This indicates the existence of culture-specific sound preferences which represent a field of possible future study within audionarratology.

 

January 2017: Agatha Frischmuth is a PhD candidate and teaching fellow at the Peter Szondi-Institute for Comparative Literature at the Free University of Berlin. She has won a three-year scholarship for her dissertation project on the narration of inactivity in 20th and 21st century prose, in which she focuses on Polish, German, French, and Serbian literature. Her research considers the changing status of the literary “event” from early modern times to postmodernity as well as its dependence on perception and action. Her work combines narratological analyses with phenomenology as well as theatre and film studies to examine techniques of dramatization and literary visuality. She has recently published a study on the precarious event in Andrzej Stasiuks Przez rzekę in Wiener Slawistischer Almanach

 

 

Leung, Man-tat Terence . 2017. Utopia and Its Otherwise: Revolutionary Youthfulness, Lyricism, and Alternative Quests for the "East" in Kundera's Life is Elsewhere. Partial Answers 15(1): 23-46. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/646671. Publisher's Version

Contrary to widespread celebrations of the Western sixties as the antiauthoritarian heyday of “shining youthfulness” and “revolutionary lyricism” in contemporary cultures, Milan Kundera’s novel Život je jinde (Life Is Elsewhere), written shortly after the Soviet invasions of Czechoslovakia in 1968, exposes the narcissistic underside of this subversive epoch through a highly subjective juxtaposition of the two major historical events that happened in the same year in Eastern and Western Europe — Prague Spring and French May ’68. While Kudera’s idiosyncratic historical perspective, which perceived the Prague 1968 as more important than the May uprisings in Paris, may infuriate many Western readers, I argue that the book Život je jinde does not entertain a totally dismissive, unsympathetic attitude towards the revolutionary traditions of modern Europe at large. Relatively ignored by the critical world ever since its publication, Life Is Elsewhere not only outlines some radically alternative visions of the European sixties but also provides innovative ways to problematize the epistemological and ideological confines implicitly attached to the currently reigning liberal-democratic capitalism.

 

January 2017: Man-tat Terence Leung received his Ph. D. degree in Humanities and Creative Writing from Hong Kong Baptist University. Several of his manuscripts on various subjects, including Kieślowski’s cinema and Godard-Gorin’s militant films, have been accepted for publication in internationally refereed edited volumes (Intimate Relationships in Cinema, Literature and Visual Culture [Palgrave Macmillan] and 1968 and Global Cinema [Wayne State University Press]). He is now preparing his first monograph tentatively titled, “The Dialectics of Two Refusals: French May ’68 and Its Chinese Nexus in Western Cinematic Imaginaries since the 1960s” (under review). Leung is currently a full-time lecturer in General Education (Film, Cultural Studies and World Civilizations) in the School of Professional Education and Executive Development at Hong Kong Polytechnic University.

 

 

Reichel, A.Elisabeth . 2017. Musical Macrostructures in The Gold Bug Variations and Orfeo by Richard Powers; or, toward a Media-Conscious Audionarratology. Partial Answers 15(1): 81-98. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/646675. Publisher's Version

Audionarratology is enmeshed in the current trend toward media-consciousness in narratological debates. This article connect audionarratological concerns with the (trans- or inter)medial extensions of narratology offered by scholars such as Marie-Laure Ryan and Werner Wolf. It focuses on Richard Powers’s earliest musical novel, The Gold Bug Variations (1991), and his to-date latest novel Orfeo (2014), zooming in on their musical macrostructures, the musical forms and techniques that inform the narrative arrangement of the texts. Having positioned the narrative analysis of macrostructural musical elements within the research scope of a media-conscious audionarratology and having explored The Gold Bug Variations and Orfeo for such musical macrostructures, I reflect on the functions of imitating music in this way.

 

January 2017: A. Elisabeth Reichel holds an M.A. in Anglophone literary and cultural studies from the University of Mannheim, Germany. In her M.A. thesis, titled “Fictionalizing Music, Musicalizing Fiction: The Integrative Function of Music in Richard Powers’s The Time of Our Singing,” she examined the political functions of music from a perspective informed by sound studies as well as word and music studies. Currently, she is writing a Ph.D. thesis on “Sounding Primitives, Writing Anthropologists: The Poetry and Scholarship of Edward Sapir, Margaret Mead, and Ruth Benedict” as a member of the interdisciplinary research project “Of Cultural, Poetic, and Medial Alterity” at the University of Basel, Switzerland. She has taught at the universities of Basel, Berne, and Mannheim. In her publications and presentations, she investigates literary constructions of sonic and musical alterity, writing as a colonial technique, and the intersections between literary studies and the history of cultural anthropology.